Leo+DadMade for Leo
Devices
Rung 3 of 4 · The traps

When Devices Backfire

Three traps catch people who've just learned to name devices: overuse that numbs, confusing the device with the appeal, and thinking that naming a device is the same as analysing it.

NESA EN4-ECA-01 Builds on: naming the device

Explore Drag the density slider from punchy to exhausting — then match each device to the effect it has on a listener.
🎧
Audio WalkthroughDad & Leo, Two Minutes — Coming Soon
Video ExplainerComing Soon

Trap One: Too Much of a Good Thing

The moment you can name devices, the temptation is to cram in as many as possible. Resist it. Devices are spice, not the meal. Put everything in threes, repeat every phrase, end every sentence with a rhetorical question, and the listener stops hearing the message and starts noticing the technique. When everything is emphasised, nothing is — the punch numbs into noise.

Say it plainly: the sweet spot is one strong device, well placed — not every device, every line. Drag the slider in the toy and watch the same idea go from sharp to suffocating.

Trap Two: a Device Is Not an Appeal

This one trips up even good students. A device is the tool; an appeal is the job the tool is doing. A rhetorical question is a device — but whether it's pulling logos (making you reason) or pathos (making you feel) depends on the question. “Can we really afford to wait?” leans pathos; “If three streets flood now, what happens with twice the rain?” leans logos. Same device, different appeal. Remember the link back to ethos, pathos and logos: devices carry appeals.

Trap Three: Naming Isn't Analysing

Spotting “that's anaphora” is step one, not the answer. The marks live in saying what the device does to the listener: anaphora builds an unstoppable drumbeat; a tricolon gives a sense of completeness; antithesis sharpens a choice by clashing two opposites. Name the tool, then name the effect.

Exam-saver: never stop at “the writer uses a rhetorical question.” Always add the effect: which device, how it positions the responder, and what feeling or thought it pushes them toward. That second half is the whole game.

Us, Thinking Out Loud

Can you find an advert or speech that overdoes a device until it stops working?

Take one device and write the effect half of the sentence — what does it actually do to the listener?