Leo+DadMade for Leo
Interpreting Data in Graphs
Rung 3 of 4 · The traps

When a Graph Tries to Fool You

A graph can be perfectly accurate and still lie to your eyes. The classic trick is a sneaky axis — and once you've seen it, you'll catch it everywhere, especially in ads and the news.

NESA MA4-DAT-C-02The traps

Spot itFlip the axis between “as they drew it” and “from zero”. Same two numbers — see how the story changes.
🎧
Audio WalkthroughComing Soon
Video ExplainerComing Soon

Here's the uncomfortable truth: a graph can show the exact right numbers and still give you the wrong impression. The most common stunt is starting the up-the-side scale somewhere other than zero — so a tiny difference balloons into a cliff.

The Truncated Axis

In the toy, two values like 36 and 32 are almost the same — a real difference of just 4. But start the axis at 30 instead of 0 and suddenly one bar looks twice as tall as the other. Nothing's been faked; the numbers are honest. The scale is doing the lying. Flip to "from zero" and the bars snap back to the truth: barely any gap at all.

Say it plainly: always check where the y-axis starts. If it doesn't start at 0, the bar heights are exaggerated — read the actual numbers, not the picture.

Other Ways Graphs Mislead

Watch for uneven steps on the scale (jumping 0, 10, 50, 100 so the spacing lies), and for reading between the gridlines — if a bar lands halfway between 40 and 50, it's about 45, not whatever the nearest line says. And the sneakiest of all: correlation isn't cause. Two lines rising together (ice-cream sales and sunburn, say) doesn't mean one caused the other — they might just both follow the hot weather.

Why This Matters

Whoever draws a graph chooses the scale, and they don't always choose it to help you. The defence is simple and it never fails: read the actual numbers off the axis before you trust the shape. A picture can shout; the numbers tell the truth.

Us, Thinking Out Loud

Why does starting the axis above zero make a small gap look huge?

Can you think of two things that rise together but don't cause each other?